The Care Ledger

Research and data Surprise-billing arbitration added $8.39 billion to employer plan costs, EBRI estimates

Search
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Today's Paper From the publisher Free hospital price search Published bysoro
The Care Ledger

Research and data

Surprise-billing arbitration added $8.39 billion to employer plan costs, EBRI estimates

A new estimate puts a dollar figure on what the No Surprises Act's dispute process cost job-based health plans last year, a cost employers say ends up in workers' premiums.

A brick hospital building with red EMERGENCY signs over the entrance and cars parked in front
A hospital emergency department entrance. Photo: Harrison Keely, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

Arbitration awards under the No Surprises Act left employer health plans owing an estimated $8.39 billion more to out-of-network providers in 2025 than the plans first paid, according to an issue brief released November 121 by the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI). That is about 0.625% of the $1.342 trillion spent on employment-based coverage nationwide, or roughly $46 per covered person per year.

Why it matters

The No Surprises Act took effect in 2022 to keep patients out of the middle of billing fights between out-of-network providers and health plans. When the two sides cannot agree on a price, either can take the claim to federal independent dispute resolution (IDR), where an arbiter picks one side's offer.

Patients are protected from the bill itself. The cost of those awards does not disappear, though. It is paid by health plans, and for most workers that means an employer plan whose costs feed into next year's premiums. EBRI's brief is one of the first attempts to measure that cost directly from federal data.

How EBRI got the number

The study, written by Paul Fronstin, director of health benefits research at EBRI, uses public files from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) on 2025 IDR decisions. For each case, it takes the award and subtracts the plan's initial payment and the patient's cost sharing. What remains is the additional amount the plan owes because of the arbitration.

CMS began including initial payment and cost-sharing amounts in its files in the second half of 2025. For that half, EBRI calculated $4.726 billion in added obligations directly. For the first half, it estimated $3.662 billion. Among people under 65, the full-year total works out to about $50 a person.

EBRI set aside 27 awards above $1 million or below negative $1 million as likely data errors, Insurance Business reported2. Providers won about 85% of decisions in the second half of the year, down from 88% in the first, according to the same report.

What the figure does not show

EBRI is careful about the limits. The brief says the 0.625% measures the size of added obligations from federal awards, not the law's overall effect on premiums or spending. It leaves out administrative fees and the larger share of out-of-network claims settled before they reach arbitration.

The estimate also assumes every award is paid in full, which CMS data do not confirm. Fronstin told Insurance Business the effect on premiums is "a small impact," but not zero.

Context

The dispute process has grown far beyond what regulators planned. They expected about 17,000 disputes a year. There were about 2.5 million in 2025, and 2026 is on track to pass 4 million, Georgetown University researcher Jack Hoadley said at a November 12 event, Healthcare Dive reported3. Georgetown research has tied the process to more than $22 billion in added spending over four years.

Insurers and employers say these costs are a growing burden that will reach consumers through higher premiums. Physician groups have opposed proposals to scale arbitration back.

What comes next

At the same Georgetown event, an aide to Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-La.), the outgoing chair of the Senate health committee, said Cassidy will soon release what he called comprehensive legislation to reform the dispute process. The aide listed tighter oversight of arbiters, more transparency, protecting employers from unnecessary costs, faster payment to providers and fewer incentives to arbitrate.

A rival bill from Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.) would end arbitration and tie out-of-network payments to in-network rates. Insurers back that approach and physicians oppose it. A policy analyst at the Paragon Health Institute said at the event that action before the year ends is unlikely and pointed to 2027.

  • 01

    UnitedHealth's outside review of its coverage rules skips denials

    A review by FTI Consulting and Rubrum Advising, released November 12, tested nine of UnitedHealthcare's medical policies and called the process sound, but it did not assess how the policies are applied in coverage decisions or any cost considerations.

    Healthcare Dive

  • 02

    Kentucky cancels another $50 million in medical debt

    Gov. Andy Beshear said the Team Kentucky Medical Debt Relief program is clearing debt for about 22,000 residents, with letters going out this week.

    WBKO

  • 03

    North Dakota's $25 insulin cap misses many workers

    The cap applies only to state-regulated plans, so most large employer plans fall outside it; 29 states now cap insulin copays, according to the American Diabetes Association.

    KFF Health News

Every figure in this story was checked against these sources on Friday, November 13, 2026.

  1. 01Employee Benefit Research Institute, "The Federal Independent Dispute Resolution Process and Employment-Based Health Plan Costs", November 12, 2026ebri.org
  2. 02Insurance Business, "No Surprises Act IDR process adds $8.39bn to health plan costs", November 12, 2026insurancebusinessmag.com
  3. 03Healthcare Dive, "Cassidy aide pledges No Surprises fix coming soon", November 13, 2026healthcaredive.com
  4. 04Healthcare Dive, "UnitedHealth review of medical policies finds gaps, does not assess denials", November 12, 2026healthcaredive.com
  5. 05WBKO, "Governor Beshear announces more medical debt cancellations for Kentuckians", November 12, 2026wbko.com
  6. 06KFF Health News, "North Dakota insulin copay cap", November 13, 2026kffhealthnews.org
  7. PhotoA hospital emergency department entrance. Photo: Harrison Keely, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0).commons.wikimedia.org
  1. Research and data

    Hospital and insurer price files match exactly on 10.8% of rates, Trilliant finds

    A new study of the price data hospitals and health plans must publish finds the two sources often list different prices for the same service at the same hospital, and that commercial rates for one surgery can vary more than eightfold.

    3 min read

  2. Research and data

    Medicare patients at rural clinics often pay more than a 20% share, MedPAC staff find

    Because coinsurance at rural health clinics is set by what each clinic charges, many traditional Medicare patients owe about a third of the visit's rate instead of the usual 20%, and the gap is growing.

    3 min read

  3. Research and data

    Half of working-age adults went without needed care because of cost, survey finds

    The Commonwealth Fund's biennial insurance survey found cost-related barriers to care rising since 2022, including among adults who had coverage all year.

    3 min read

  4. Research and data

    Workers' cost for family coverage rose 9% to $7,471 in 2026, KFF survey finds

    KFF's annual survey of employers found that what workers pay toward family coverage grew almost twice as fast as the total premium this year, with the heaviest bills at small firms.

    2 min read