The Care Ledger

Research and data Medicare patients at rural clinics often pay more than a 20% share, MedPAC staff find

Search
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Today's Paper From the publisher Free hospital price search Published bysoro
The Care Ledger

Research and data

Medicare patients at rural clinics often pay more than a 20% share, MedPAC staff find

Because coinsurance at rural health clinics is set by what each clinic charges, many traditional Medicare patients owe about a third of the visit's rate instead of the usual 20%, and the gap is growing.

A single-story health center with a brick and dark-panel front behind a parking lot of pickup trucks and cars
The Montezuma Creek Community Health Center in Montezuma Creek, Utah. Photo: Steven Baltakatei Sandoval, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Traditional Medicare patients who visit independent rural health clinics paid an average of $48 a visit in coinsurance in 2025, or 36% of the clinics' estimated Medicare rate, according to a staff analysis presented to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) on Thursday. The figure is well above the 20% share most people expect to pay under Medicare Part B. The findings are preliminary and are not a commission recommendation.

The reason is a quirk in how these clinics are paid. Medicare pays a rural health clinic 80% of a per-visit rate based on the clinic's costs, within payment limits. The patient's 20% coinsurance, however, is calculated from the clinic's own charges, not from that rate, the slides explain1. A clinic that sets higher charges collects more from its patients while Medicare's share stays the same.

What patients pay

MedPAC staff illustrated the effect with three independent clinics that each received the same $106 Medicare payment per visit in 2025. Patients at the lowest-charging clinic paid $26 in coinsurance, while patients at the highest-charging clinic paid $74. Total revenue per visit ran from $133 to $181.

Across independent clinics, the median coinsurance came to 32% of the estimated Medicare rate, and at the 90th percentile it reached 54%, according to the analysis. Clinics that are part of a hospital with fewer than 50 beds, which have much higher Medicare rates, saw coinsurance closer to the standard 20%.

About 5,200 rural health clinics billed traditional Medicare in 2025, treating 2.3 million patients over 10.3 million visits, with about $2.3 billion in payments, MedPAC staff reported.

Why the gap is widening

The staff analysis found that charges are rising faster than Medicare's rates. From 2018 to 2025, charges per visit at independent clinics grew an average of 6.6% a year, compared with 2.8% a year for the Medicare Economic Index, the inflation measure Medicare uses to update payment limits. Because patients' coinsurance follows charges, staff said it is likely to keep growing faster than Medicare's payments.

The analysis also tied the trend to a change in law. Starting in 2021, Congress raised the payment limits for independent clinics, and MedPAC staff said the national per-visit limit will rise 120% from 2020 to 2028. Growth in the number of independent clinics billing Medicare picked up after the higher limits began, and staff said some of that growth came from private equity-owned clinics.

The same rule does not apply to every visit. For telehealth visits that are not for mental health, which Medicare pays at a lower rate through 2027, coinsurance is capped at 20% of that rate. In 2025 that rate was $97, according to the slides.

The option on the table

Staff asked commissioners to consider setting rural clinic coinsurance at 20% of the lesser of the clinic's Medicare rate or its charges. Had that applied in 2025, the analysis estimated, patient coinsurance would have fallen 24% overall and 44% at independent clinics. Total Medicare payments to rural clinics, including what patients pay, would have dropped 5%, and 14% at independent clinics, because Medicare's own share would not change.

The idea mirrors a step MedPAC has already taken. In June 2025, the commission recommended that Congress base coinsurance at critical access hospitals on Medicare's payment amount rather than on hospital charges. That recommendation did not cover rural health clinics.

What comes next

Commissioners discussed the analysis at their meeting on November 5. Staff asked for direction on further work, including more interviews with clinics, a possible phase-in, and options to soften the revenue loss for clinics. MedPAC advises Congress and cannot change Medicare's rules on its own, so any change to how rural clinic coinsurance is set would require action by Congress.

  • 01

    Federal agencies drop two surprise-billing arbiters

    HHS, Labor and Treasury denied recertification to IPRO and Network Medical Review Company, saying both failed minimum performance standards under the No Surprises Act, and are reviewing petitions on eight other arbitration firms.

    CMS

  • 02

    Cigna's pharmacy benefit profit falls 22%

    Pre-tax adjusted operating income at Express Scripts' parent segment fell to $765 million in the third quarter from $975 million a year earlier, and pharmacy customers dropped to 117.7 million from 122.5 million.

    Cigna

  • 03

    Medicare drug negotiation gets a permanent rulebook

    A final rule issued Thursday sets the program's rules for prices starting in 2029, with up to 20 drugs selected a year, and treats a drug reformulated with an added ingredient such as hyaluronidase as the same drug.

    CMS

  • 04

    Ballad Health and UnitedHealthcare sign a Medicare Advantage deal

    The multi-year agreement keeps UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage individual and group retiree members in network at the Tennessee and Virginia health system. No financial terms were disclosed.

    Ballad Health

Every figure in this story was checked against these sources on Friday, November 6, 2026.

  1. 01MedPAC, "Charge-based coinsurance at rural health clinics" (staff presentation by Brian O'Donnell and Alex Harris), November 5, 2026medpac.gov
  2. 02MedPAC, "November 5-6, 2026 public meeting", November 5, 2026medpac.gov
  3. 03Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "No Surprises Act notices" (IDR entity recertification denials), November 4, 2026cms.gov
  4. 04The Cigna Group, "Third quarter 2026 results" (Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1), November 5, 2026sec.gov
  5. 05Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, "Medicare Drug Price Negotiation Program final rule (CMS-4215-F)" fact sheet, November 5, 2026cms.gov
  6. 06Ballad Health, "UnitedHealthcare, Ballad Health reach multi-year agreement for people enrolled in Medicare Advantage", November 5, 2026balladhealth.org
  7. PhotoThe Montezuma Creek Community Health Center in Montezuma Creek, Utah. Photo: Steven Baltakatei Sandoval, via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).commons.wikimedia.org
  1. Research and data

    Surprise-billing arbitration added $8.39 billion to employer plan costs, EBRI estimates

    A new estimate puts a dollar figure on what the No Surprises Act's dispute process cost job-based health plans last year, a cost employers say ends up in workers' premiums.

    3 min read

  2. Research and data

    Hospital and insurer price files match exactly on 10.8% of rates, Trilliant finds

    A new study of the price data hospitals and health plans must publish finds the two sources often list different prices for the same service at the same hospital, and that commercial rates for one surgery can vary more than eightfold.

    3 min read

  3. Research and data

    Half of working-age adults went without needed care because of cost, survey finds

    The Commonwealth Fund's biennial insurance survey found cost-related barriers to care rising since 2022, including among adults who had coverage all year.

    3 min read

  4. Research and data

    Workers' cost for family coverage rose 9% to $7,471 in 2026, KFF survey finds

    KFF's annual survey of employers found that what workers pay toward family coverage grew almost twice as fast as the total premium this year, with the heaviest bills at small firms.

    2 min read