Air ambulance firm PHI Health is suing employers to collect surprise-billing awards
An air ambulance company is taking unpaid No Surprises Act arbitration awards to the employers whose health plans owe them, putting the cost of the dispute process directly on the companies that fund workers' coverage.

PHI Health, an air ambulance operator, has sued hundreds of companies to collect tens of millions of dollars in arbitration awards that it says insurers have not paid in full, STAT reported1 on Wednesday. The named defendants include Amazon, Walmart, Eli Lilly, General Motors, PepsiCo and United Airlines, along with counties, towns, public school districts, unions and the Catholic Diocese of Cleveland. All of the cases are pending, and no court has ruled.
Why it matters for what people pay
In a self-funded health plan, the employer pays workers' claims and an insurer such as Anthem often administers them. When an arbitrator sets a payment above what such a plan first paid, the difference comes out of the employer's plan, and employers generally recover rising plan costs through workers' premium contributions and wages. Garrett Hohimer, a vice president at the Business Group on Health, told STAT the suits are "an escalation" that will push employers' health plan costs up.
The dispute process the awards come from has grown far more expensive than its designers expected. Researchers Jack Hoadley and Kennah Watts estimate in Health Affairs Forefront2 that independent dispute resolution (IDR) cost $22.4 billion from 2022 to 2025, including $15.6 billion in payments above the plans' qualifying payment amount from 2023 to 2025. They note that this measures added payments and fees, not the law's overall effect on spending.
The details
The cases range from global companies to small employers. A family plumbing business in Frankfort, Ky., with about 30 employees was sued in August for almost $27,000 over a retired worker's emergency helicopter flight, along with 31 other companies, STAT reported. PHI dropped the business in September; its coverage is fully insured through Anthem, which means the insurer, not the employer, bears the claims. Spotsylvania County Public Schools in Virginia faces a claim of almost $28,000, and the Town of Bridgewater, Va., was sued in October for more than $37,000.
PHI argues that an employer that knows its plan is not paying awards, and goes along with it, shares responsibility. It says Medicare rates do not cover the cost of emergency air transport. In a 2024 filing3 with the Securities and Exchange Commission, PHI said its arbitration win rate was above the 71% industry average that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) reported for parties that start a dispute.
Elevance Health, which owns Anthem and is often named alongside the employers, said in a statement to STAT that PHI charges 700% of what Medicare pays for air ambulance service and mileage rates 1,500% above Medicare. Elevance said it has already paid PHI substantial amounts and disputes that more is owed on claims it considers ineligible for arbitration. James Gelfand, chief executive of the ERISA Industry Committee, which lobbies for large employers, told STAT that employers have a fiduciary duty to spend plan money carefully, and that paying awards on ineligible claims or at unusually high amounts could breach it.
How the process got here
The No Surprises Act took effect in 2022. It shields insured patients from most surprise out-of-network bills, including for emergency air ambulance flights, and sends payment disputes between providers and plans to an arbitrator whose decision is binding. Federal agencies originally expected about 22,000 disputes a year, according to the Georgetown analysis. Providers started 2.6 million in 2025 alone, up 77% from 2024, and won about 85% of the disputes decided that year. The median winning provider award in 2025 was 445% of the qualifying payment amount, a benchmark tied to the plan's median in-network rate.
What comes next
The lawsuits will move through the courts one at a time, and none has a scheduled ruling. Congress is weighing proposals to change the arbitration process, STAT reported, including one from a House Democrat. The questions to watch are whether courts accept that an employer can be held liable for an award its insurer administers, and whether lawmakers act before more providers follow PHI's approach.



